About PracticeAlert

Find out about Physician Jobs in your geographic areas of interest:
● It's free for Physicians. ● No Recruiting Firms. ● Geographically Targeted Searches. ● Maintain Confidentiality.
Register Now

Check out our LinkedIn page:

Is Physician Employment Really the Best Career Choice?

Posted on | Posted By | 0 Comments

Is the security and stability that is supposed to come with hospital employment really a grand deception? Are physicians simultaneously being fooled and fooling themselves into thinking their careers will be better if they succumb to a corporate overlord and a binding institutional contract?

This is precisely what Mark F. Weiss, JD, wonders in a recent article at Anesthesiology News.

Basically, Weiss is challenging the notion that hospital employment of physicians is better than staying in private practice. He reminds physicians that the current corporate environment is actually unstable, with many businesses reducing their labor force to part-time, replacing staff with temps, and outsourcing as much as possible.

Recently, for example, Merck laid off over 100 employees, Heinz bade farewell to 600 employees, and Cisco axed an astounding 4,000 employees. If these big-namers are launching such massive scalebacks, Weiss wonders, why would hospitals be immune, especially in an era of declining reimbursements, intensely escalating federal and state regulations, etc.?

Furthermore, the government’s employment numbers are highly misleading, Weiss writes. “Only 23 percent of the approximately 950,000 jobs the economy added from January to July 2013 are full-time. The remaining 730,000 of those jobs are part-time positions.”

“…[W]hy the disconnect?” he wonders. “Why do many physicians believe that employment in hospitals, hospital-captive medical groups or large staffing-model groups provides safety or stability when the world around them for other employees—unskilled, skilled, and professional—is in turmoil?”

Remember, he urges: “Corporations exist to make a profit. There’s nothing wrong with that. It’s a fact of life. But because all corporations, and that includes hospitals and especially staffing service-model groups, exist to make a profit, they will always seek to lower their costs. Of course, costs include employment costs, which includes salaries…”

Weiss realizes the alleged benefits physicians see in hospital employment: “It’s less complicated than running a group; my employer will find work for me; there is no need to compete for the exclusive contract; I may earn less, but at least I’ll have stability.” But he fears some romanticizing is going on. In a physician’s mind, they see the following: show up for work; collect a paycheck; go home.

“But healthcare employers are not substitute parents,” he writes. “Sure, parents may kick you out of the house, but employers fire you or lay you off and never invite you back for the holidays. The same trends affecting industry in general, leading to layoffs, part-time and temp work, also are affecting healthcare.”

As proof, he offered up the names of hospitals all of whom recently laid off employees. It’s true, no physicians were victims of these layoffs, he hastens to add, but “with more physicians employed by large organizations, it is only a matter of time before they, too, are affected by cutbacks.” And the nonprofit status of most hospitals really doesn’t impact their ability or desire to cut back on costs, since they, too, are corporations.

He concludes: “The urge to seek security is entirely human and virtually universal. But what appears safe in today’s healthcare economy, what appears less complicated in today’s healthcare economy, and what is clearly the trend in today’s economy—employment by hospitals—is far more risky than it appears.” And if you think it isn’t, “You’re fooling yourself. The reality is that the only safety that exists is within you. The reality is that you are self-employed no matter whether your paycheck comes from the largest hospital chain in the nation or from your solo practice. The only difference is who can tell you when to stop working.”

As physicians looking for jobs, do you think that Weiss puts forth some valid points? What is your opinion of the hospital-employment trend among physicians? Are you seeking hospital employment? If so, what benefits do you hope to gain from such employment?

Terms of Use  -  Privacy Policy  -  HealthLinkDimensions.com

Privacy Notice: Your IP address is IP addresses are logged and tracked to maintain the integrity of our service.